Infinite Families of Counterexamples to a Conjecture of Liu and Qian and a Refined Inverse Theorem for Restricted Sumsets in $\mathbb{Z}_p$

RESUMO

Let $p$ be a prime and let $A,B$ be nonempty subsets of the cyclic group $\mathbb{Z}_p$ with $|A|\neq |B|$. The Alon--Nathanson--Ruzsa theorem gives the lower bound $|A\rplus B|\ge \min\{p,\,|A|+|B|-2\},$ where $A\rplus B=\{a+b:a\in A,\ b\in B,\ a\neq b\}$ is the restricted sumset. The inverse problem of characterizing all critical pairs $(A,B)$ attaining equality was posed by Alon, Nathanson, and Ruzsa in 1996 and remains open. Recently, Liu and Qian solved the inverse problem under the assumption that at least one of the sets is an arithmetic progression, and proposed a conjecture for the general case. The main purpose of this paper is to show that this conjecture fails in the boundary case $|A|+|B|=p$. More precisely, we construct infinite families of non-arithmetic critical pairs $(A,B)$ with $|A|+|B|=p$ and $|A\rplus B|=p-2$ for every prime $p\ge 11$. These families show that the boundary case is fundamentally different from the non-boundary case. Motivated by this, we formulate and prove a refined inverse theorem under the natural hypothesis $|A|+|B|\le p-1$, which excludes the boundary.