Early Epistemic Settlement in AI-Assisted Writing

RESUMO

In trying to complete a passage, an author can make connections among her materials that change what she can argue and the demands the argument must meet. A language model can supply a passage that does the work required at that point in her argument. Accepting it can end her own attempts before those connections have developed. I call this interruption early epistemic settlement. It can occur even when she fully understands the response and correctly judges it adequate for the passage's present role in the argument. The answer can satisfy the desire for resolution that kept her at work. Returning to her unfinished attempt would take more effort, and she may be unable to anticipate what she could achieve by continuing it. With repeated assistance, accepted answers shape what the writer asks next and which relations she goes on to develop. Useful answers can thus sustain inquiry while cutting short the work through which an author could form arguments that accommodate demands she has yet to recognize.